The Sheff

The history of Bakewell Pudding, the happy accident that became a Peak District icon

Thank goodness for that clumsy cook

Daisy Jackson Daisy Jackson - 14th October 2026

Nestled in the heart of the Peak District National Park, the picturesque market town of Bakewell is famous for its charming streets, beautiful countryside and, of course, its namesake dessert.

But before you start thinking of the familiar iced Bakewell tart, there’s another local delicacy you need to know about - the original Bakewell pudding.

And its story begins with a kitchen mishap.

Legend has it that around 1860, a cook at a local inn called The White Horse was preparing a strawberry tart for some visiting noblemen. Following a misunderstanding with the inn’s mistress, Mrs Greaves, the cook spread an egg mixture over the jam rather than mixing it into the pastry.

The result was an unexpected triumph. The combination of buttery pastry, sweet strawberry jam and a rich, almond-infused custard created a delicious new pudding that would become a Derbyshire favourite.

Word of the creation reached Mrs Wilson, who recognised its potential and acquired the original recipe to begin selling the puddings herself. More than 160 years later, that happy accident remains at the heart of Bakewell’s culinary heritage.

Today, you can discover the story for yourself at The Old Original Bakewell Pudding Shop, right in the town centre. Housed in a historic 17th-century building, the shop has been selling its famous puddings from the same premises since 1860.

Step inside and you’ll find a treasure trove of handmade treats, from traditional Bakewell puddings and iced tarts to fresh bread, cakes and savoury pastries. There are also gifts and local specialities to browse, making it a perfect stop for a little edible souvenir.

There's also a traditional restaurant upstairs, where you can enjoy a hearty meal, afternoon tea or a freshly served Bakewell pudding with custard or cream, plus a 'Post a Pudding' service, so you can send a taste of the Peak District to friends and family further afield.

Despite often being confused, Bakewell pudding and Bakewell tart are quite different. The original pudding features flaky puff pastry, strawberry jam and a soft-set almond custard, while the later tart uses shortcrust pastry and a sponge-like frangipane filling, often finished with icing and a cherry.

So, next time you’re exploring the Peak District, make a beeline for Bakewell. Whether you enjoy yours warm with custard or take one home to share, tasting this legendary pudding is a delicious way to experience a little piece of local history.

Read more: The Hillsborough butcher serving up seriously good pork sandwiches

Featured image: The Sheff